Advertisement

US ‘smart city’ tech highlights contrasts with China over privacy and control

  • American communities try to balance the benefits of new technology with the threats of a surveillance state
  • China has a first-mover advantage abroad, particularly in developing nations, installing equipment based on Chinese standards

Reading Time:7 minutes
Why you can trust SCMP
42
Illustration: Henry Wong
Mark Magnierin Redwood City, California

Christian Hammack stands outside city hall and surveys his kingdom – cars at rest. The Redwood City parking manager has spent years helping transform this California city of 84,000 people near San Francisco into a model of smart city technology.

Advertisement

Parking, however smart, may seem dull. But Redwood City’s hi-tech system is helping revitalise the downtown area, increase business and tax revenue and reduce congestion, pollution and accidents, even as powerful smart city tools raise concerns.

Loosely defined, smart cities use technology-based infrastructure to collect and analyse data aimed at improving services.

“We don’t want to be recording or streaming data … like Big Brother,” said Hammack, citing privacy concerns and smart city applications in China and other authoritarian societies. “We want people to be comfortable with any system we implement. While we want to manage parking – it’s for the public, for their benefit.”

Christian Hammack is Redwood City’s parking manager. Photo: Mark Magnier
Christian Hammack is Redwood City’s parking manager. Photo: Mark Magnier
Even as Beijing faces growing international criticism for powerful tracking technologies driving its social credit system, mobile applications and suppression in Xinjiang – where up to 1 million Uygurs have been detained in camps that Beijing calls employment centres – the United States is grappling with its own issues in the struggle to balance smart city and surveillance state.
Advertisement

As sensor, artificial intelligence, drones and voiceprint technologies advance rapidly, they promise to reduce crime, the cost of living and global warming – even as technical advances race ahead of law and privacy safeguards.

Advertisement